Hun Sen ‘win-win’ legacy debated on Khmer Rouge fall anniversary | Cambodia Information




I want to share Stories and images for publishing Whatapp News


Anlong Veng, Cambodia – In late 1998, Peng Samonn, a war-weary Khmer Rouge cadre who had spent a long time combating within the jungles on the Thai border, obtained wind of a secret plot to abandon the infamous ultra-communists and be a part of Cambodia’s authorities forces.

“A Khmer Rouge commander instructed me about divisions and that there could be a defection quickly, so to unfold the information,” 70-year-old Samonn mentioned earlier this month, sitting outdoors the identical dwelling he lived in below the Khmer Rouge.

“But when one other faction had came upon, I might have been killed. I shared it with 10 households and all of us fled.”

Led by army chief Pol Pot, the Khmer Rouge authorities hadvert been overthrown nearly precisely 20 years earlier than that incident by Vietnamese-backed forces. Round 1.7 million Cambodians had perished in lower than 4 years (1975-1979) on account of hunger, sickness, overwork and homicide because the Khmer Rouge’s disastrous agrarian revolution unfolded.

Regardless of their defeat, the Khmer Rouge continued to battle on, retreating to distant areas and controlling small pockets of the nation up till late 1998. Anlong Veng was their last stronghold, overseen by the much-feared Ta Mok, a senior Khmer Rouge chief who died in 2006 whereas awaiting trial for genocide and crimes in opposition to humanity.

Yim Choeun skilled first-hand the ruthlessness of Ta Mok within the 1990s.The 61-year-old presently lives on a sizeable plot of land a brief drive from Anlong Veng city, in what was once known as the “Village of Swollen and Rotten Flesh” – a time period used for enemies and “capitalists” coined by Pol Pot a long time earlier than.

“They accused me and me spouse of promoting pangolins to the Thais. I used to be put in a human cage,” he mentioned, including that he was solely launched resulting from a necessity for manpower amid an offensive from authorities forces.

“I didn’t count on to be alive.”



Khmer Rouge troopers line up earlier than turning into authorities military fatigues in Anlong Veng (Courtesy Documentation Middle of Cambodia/Al Jazeera]

Plans for Khmer Rouge defections to the federal government have been cultivated lengthy earlier than 1998.

In 1991, 19 counties signed the Paris Peace Accords in an effort to finish Cambodia’s civil struggle and put the nation on the trail in direction of democracy. Beneath the phrases of the settlement, the United Nations would ship a peacekeeping mission to Cambodia (UNTAC) till 1993 – the primary time the world physique would govern a state –  to oversee a truce and put together the nation for a brand new structure and free and honest elections. 

Many within the Khmer Rouge strongholds hoped that the accords might deliver an finish to the struggle. These hopes, nonetheless, have been dashed when the Khmer Rouge management boycotted the 1993 nationwide elections and vowed to proceed the battle.

The vote was received by Funcinpec, a royalist social gathering led by Prince Norodom Ranariddh, however Hun Sen, of the Cambodian Individuals’s Celebration (CPP), managed to manoeuvre a power-sharing settlement. A former Khmer Rouge commander, Hun Sen had fled to Vietnam in 1977 to affix forces opposing the group, earlier than returning to Cambodia to function minister of overseas affairs after the Vietnamese put in a brand new authorities in 1979. He turned a chief minister in 1985.

Confined in remoted areas, the Khmer Rouge grew weaker from yr to yr. By 1996, two different Khmer Rouge strongholds in Pailin and Malai had reintegrated with the federal government, elevating alarm bells in Anlong Veng.

Ta Mok then tried negotiations with Funcinpec royalists behind the again of Pol Pot. The transfer appeared to behave as a catalyst for factional combating between forces loyal to Funcinpec and to CPP in 1997, ensuing within the latter securing full management till at the present time, in what many outline as a coup d’etat.

Over the subsequent yr, the Khmer Rouge disintegrated additional by way of infighting, in addition to defections to the federal government below Prime Minister Hun Sen’s self-styled “win-win” coverage which noticed the peaceable reintegation of former fighters into Cambodian society.

“On December 4, 1998, each side reached an settlement marking the ultimate chapter of the KR (Khmer Rouge) defection and supreme dissolution of the KR remnants who had struggled in opposition to the federal government for practically twenty-eight years,” wrote Dy Khamboly and Christopher Dearing in A Historical past of the Anlong Veng Neighborhood.

“As well as, all former KR troopers and civilians could be recognised as authorized residents of Cambodia, with the precise to retain their present property in addition to maintain administrative positions within the space.”

In a set of extremely orchestrated “reintegration” ceremonies in Anlong Veng in early 1999, Khmer Rouge troopers downed their weapons and become authorities fatigues.

Hun Sen’s “win-win” coverage was accomplished.



Khmer Rouge cadres stand in entrance of piles of weapons throughout a reintegration ceremony in Anlong Veng in early 1999 [Courtesy Documentation Center of Cambodia/Al Jazeera]

On Saturday, tens of 1000’s of individuals are anticipated to attend the inauguration of the “Win-Win Monument” within the capital, Phnom Penh, to have fun 20 years for the reason that Khmer Rouge lastly fell and two of its leaders – Nuon Chea and Khieu Samphan – visited Hun Sen for peace talks. Each at the moment are serving double life sentences for crimes, together with genocide.

Hun Sen has lengthy credited the “win-win coverage” for terminating the combating, touting the tip of the civil struggle as maybe his biggest achievement. However whereas this was a landmark second in latest Cambodian historical past, Hun Sen has additionally been accused of utilizing the time period for ulterior motives.

Final yr, shortly earlier than the extremely controversial dissolution of his solely credible electoral menace, the Cambodia Nationwide Rescue Celebration, Hun Sen had instructed opposition commune councillors that they may maintain on to their jobs in the event that they defected to the ruling social gathering.

“This can be a win-win coverage,” he mentioned.

Sebastian Strangio, writer of Hun Sen’s Cambodia, mentioned the prime minister deserves credit score for engineering the army offensives and political offers that led to the breakup of the Khmer Rouge.

Nevertheless, he believes Hun Sen has since exploited its legacy for his personal political targets.

“After all, this achievement has since been rolled right into a totalising political declare that raises up the CPP as the one respectable consultant of the Cambodian individuals, and paints its opponents as enemies bent on rekindling the civil struggle,” he mentioned.

“Whereas all of the ‘win-win’ discuss is to an extent based mostly on an actual achievement, it’s now used as a political cudgel to close down debate and foreclose any possible different to the present ruling social gathering.”

Political analyst Lao Mong Hay argued that, greater than something, the “win-win” coverage was a show of political opportunism on the a part of Hun Sen, who’s one the world’s longest-serving prime ministers.

“What he did was only a of entirety to finish the struggle. It was morally questionable, surrendering to evil then rewarding the evil doers, the Khmer Rouge,” mentioned Mong Hay, including that the transfer was right down to Hun Sen’s efforts to legitimise his rule after dropping the 1993 elections to Funcinpec.

Mong Hay additionally agued it was an try and undermine UNTAC, which oversaw the 1993 poll however failed to finish the civil struggle.

“The CPP misplaced the election, which means its rule from 1991 was not respectable and confirmed the acknowledgment by the worldwide neighborhood that the regime was a puppet of Vietnam. That issue contributed to Hun Sen extolling his ‘win-win’ coverage’,” mentioned Mong Hay.

“It was like a molehill become a mountain.”



A billboard of Prime Minister Hun Sen subsequent to Ta Mok Lake in Anlong Veng [George Wright/Al Jazeera]

However in Anlong Veng, assist for Hun Sen and his ruling social gathering is widespread. Regardless of preliminary considerations about his assurances over the “win-win” coverage, Samonn is grateful that himself and others have been allowed to hold on with their lives in peace.

“Proper after the reintegration and ‘win-win’ coverage, I used to be sceptical as a result of the Khmer Rouge technically misplaced the struggle and from my expertise, when the Khmer Rouge got here to energy, they killed their rivals,” he mentioned.

“However Hun Sen stayed true to his phrase.”

Kheng Pha, a 64-year-old former Khmer Rouge official who’s now a CPP village chief in Anlong Veng, agrees.

“The ‘win-win coverage’ is a good coverage, it is one in all a form on this world,” he mentioned, talking beneath a poster exhibiting Hun Sen sitting in a rural subject alongside the phrases, “Our hope, our village, our nation, our future”.

“We might all win and finish the struggle, even the losers couldn’t lose. Troopers modified from communist to democrats, we had salaries,” he added.

“Communism could not win in opposition to democracy.”

Extra reporting by Phath Bora



Kheng Pha, a former Khmer Rouge soldier who’s now a ruling social gathering village chief, outdoors his dwelling in Anlong Veng [George Wright/Al Jazeera] 





Supply hyperlink

I want to share Stories and images for publishing Whatapp News

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply